Baby Gift Sets: Pretty in Pink vs Rain or Shine

By Doddle & Co | Pacifier The Pop & Go with a pinch to close ... | Published: 2026-10-13

Category: Product Reviews

Pick the right baby gift set by age and theme. Compare the Pretty in Pink and Rain or Shine bundles, plus a 5-pack chew bundle, with clear decision rules.

Quick answer

Match the bundle to the baby's age first, then to the theme. For a 0–3 month baby, choose the Pretty in Pink Bundle (0 - 3 Months). For 3+ months, the Pretty in Pink Bundle (3+ Months) includes the same three items. If you want a weather-themed mix of teethers and pacifiers, pick the Rain or Shine Bundle. For the most pieces and the biggest savings, the Rain & Shine Critter Bundle - 5 Pack is the best value.

Why age is the first filter for baby gift sets

A baby gift set only helps if the items suit the baby's current stage. The two Pretty in Pink bundles contain the same three products—Social Butterfly teether, The Pop & Go Pacifier in Make Me Blush, and Holland Pop Pacifier in Make Me Blush & Peach—but they are labeled for different age ranges. That label is your fastest way to avoid giving a gift that sits in a drawer.

If you know the baby is under 3 months, start with the 0–3 Months version. If the baby is already 3 months or older, the 3+ Months version is the better fit. When you do not know the exact age, a mixed bundle like Rain or Shine gives you more flexibility because it combines teethers and pacifiers that work across a wider window.

What each bundle actually contains

The Pretty in Pink Bundle (3+ Months) and the Pretty in Pink Bundle (0 - 3 Months) both include the Social Butterfly teether, The Pop & Go Pacifier in Make Me Blush, and the Holland Pop Pacifier in Make Me Blush & Peach. The difference is the age label, not the contents.

The Rain or Shine Bundle includes the Hello, Sunshine teether, the Looks Like Rain teether, and two London Pop Pacifiers in Smash Cake and Cloud 9. This set leans into a weather theme and gives you two different teether shapes plus two pacifiers.

The Rain & Shine Critter Bundle - 5 Pack is a chew bundle with five teethers and chews. The catalog describes it as a limited edition set of top-rated teethers and chews for sore gums and busy hands. If your goal is to build a stash of soothing options, this is the most pieces for the money.

Theme vs. variety: which matters more

A themed set like Rain or Shine works well when you are wrapping a baby shower gift and want a cohesive look. The weather theme is easy to pair with a card or a small book. A variety set like the Rain & Shine Critter Bundle is better when the parent needs options, not a matching look.

One trade-off: themed sets often repeat the same type of item. Rain or Shine includes two teethers and two pacifiers, which is balanced but not huge. The 5-pack is all chews and teethers, so it covers soothing but not pacifiers. If you want both pacifiers and teethers in one gift, the Pretty in Pink bundles cover that need.

Decision rules for choosing a baby gift bundle

If the baby is 0–3 months: Choose the Pretty in Pink Bundle (0 - 3 Months) so the age label matches the baby's stage. Skip the 3+ Months version for a newborn.
If the baby is 3 months or older: Choose the Pretty in Pink Bundle (3+ Months) or the Rain or Shine Bundle, depending on whether you want a pink theme or a weather theme. Both include teethers and pacifiers.
If you want the most items for the money: Choose the Rain & Shine Critter Bundle - 5 Pack. It has five teethers and chews and the largest catalog savings. Best for building a stash, not for a themed gift.
If you are buying for a baby shower: Pick a themed set like Rain or Shine or Pretty in Pink so the gift looks coordinated when opened. Add a card that mentions the age label so the parent knows when to use it.

Bundle facts at a glance

Pretty in Pink Bundle (3+ Months): Pretty in Pink Bundle (3+ Months) includes the Social Butterfly teether, The Pop & Go Pacifier in Make Me Blush, and the Holland Pop Pacifier in Make Me Blush & Peach. A balanced gift with one teether and two pacifiers, labeled for babies 3 months and older.
Rain or Shine Bundle: Rain or Shine Bundle includes the Hello, Sunshine teether, the Looks Like Rain teether, and the London Pop Pacifiers in Smash Cake and Cloud 9. Two teethers and two pacifiers in a weather theme, useful when you want a coordinated baby shower gift set.
Rain & Shine Critter Bundle - 5 Pack: Rain & Shine Critter Bundle - 5 Pack is a limited edition chew bundle with five top-rated teethers and chews for sore gums and busy hands. The highest piece count and the largest savings, best when the goal is a deep stash of soothing options rather than a themed gift.
Pretty in Pink Bundle (0 - 3 Months): Pretty in Pink Bundle (0 - 3 Months) includes the same three items as the 3+ Months version: Social Butterfly teether, The Pop & Go Pacifier in Make Me Blush, and Holland Pop Pacifier in Make Me Blush & Peach. Choose this version when the baby is under 3 months so the age label matches the stage.

Is a baby gift bundle right for you?

Best for

Shoppers who want a ready-made baby shower gift set with a clear theme
Parents who want to try several teethers and pacifiers without buying each separately
Gift-givers who know the baby's age and want a label that matches